The
gift tax liability on a taxable gift falls on the donor under
the gift tax rules. However, there is nothing to prevent
the donor from making the gift conditional on the donee's
paying the tax.
This type of gift is called a “net” gift. The
gift tax liability is based on the value of the taxable portion
of the gift, just as with any gift. However, the gift is
deemed to be smaller, i.e., reduced by the tax bill covered
by the donee, which in turn lowers the tax liability. Following
is an illustration of how net gifts work.
Recall that the
gift tax annual exclusion makes a certain amount given
to each donee each year nontaxable. The amount of the exclusion
is $12,000 in 2008 and $13,000 in 2009. In addition, the
amount covered by the gift tax credit for gift tax purposes
is $1 million in 2008 and 2009.
Assume that the donor made $1 million in lifetime taxable
gifts earlier, so any additional taxable gifts in 2008 (i.e.,
gifts above the $12,000 annual exclusion) result in a gift
tax liability. He wishes to give $62,000 to his nephew (which
would be a taxable gift of $50,000), but he wants his nephew
to pay the gift tax.
Under the gift tax rates, the gift falls in the 41% gift
tax bracket, so the gift tax bill would be $20,500. However,
if the nephew must pay the tax, then the gift is not $50,000,
but is only $29,500 ($50,000 − $20,500). So the gift
tax is only 41% of $29,500 ($12,095) and not $20,500. But
if the gift tax is less than $20,500, then the gift is higher
than $29,500, which would mean the gift tax liability is
higher, the gift lower, and so on and so on.
|
To
escape the above circular calculation, the IRS permits the
following formula to be used to arrive at the tax:
tentative tax/(1 + tax rate)
The tentative tax is the tax liability on the unreduced
amount of the gift, or $20,500 in the above example. Thus,
here, the tax would be $20,500/1.41 = $14,539. This makes
the gift $35,461, which is $50,000 minus $14,539. And this
result is consistent, because 41% of $35,461 equals $14,539.
Note that the net gift calculations grow more complex if
the gift falls into more than one gift tax bracket or if
a state gift tax also applies.
Keep in mind as well that the above describes a situation
in which the donee is obligated to pay the
gift tax under the terms of the gift. If the donee voluntarily covers
the tax, the treatment is different. The entire amount of
the transfer ($50,000 in the above example) is treated as
the gift and the payment of the tax ($20,500 in this case)
would be a separate transaction with no effect on the gift
amount.
Also note that under federal tax legislation enacted in
2001, the estate tax is repealed, effective 2010. However,
the gift tax was not repealed, presumably to discourage taxpayers
from making transfers to related taxpayers in lower income
brackets. Therefore, the gift tax promises to remain a powerful
consideration in the structuring of lifetime dispositions
and in estate planning. |